Kelly is a former librarian and a long-time blogger at STACKED. She's the editor/author of (DON'T) CALL ME CRAZY: 33 VOICES START THE CONVERSATION ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH and the editor/author of HERE WE ARE: FEMINISM FOR THE REAL WORLD. Her next book, BODY TALK, will publish in Fall 2020. Follow her on Instagram @heykellyjensen.
What makes a book “best?” This is always the question I ask as we enter into the two annual “best of” seasons. “Best” is subjective, based on any number of criteria determined by professional reviewers and critics, as well as readers of any given genre or style of book. For some, “best” leans heavily into literary fiction–the kinds of books that tackle Serious Topics and do so with Beautiful Language and Technical Skill. For others, “best” leans into books that were fun to read and showcased the range within a particular genre. Still for others, “best” is more like “favorite.”
None of these definitions is better or more accurate than another. In many cases, “best” is really a blend of all three.
As we march into the second half of the year, let’s reflect on what the best YA books of 2025 so far have been. To do this, I’ve pulled from Book Riot’s own Best Books of 2025 So Far list, which showcases a wide range of genres and styles within it. There are several YA entries, which you’ll see below.
From there, I then dove into the incredible database created by librarian superstars Jennifer LaGarde and Donalyn Miller that catalogs all of the starred book titles over the course of the year. Starred reviews, for those who aren’t familiar, are the highest honor a book can get in a professional trade review. These are books that stand out among all others.
Again: subjective. Starred reviews reflect contemporary taste and beliefs about what “the best” looks like. We have been lucky over the last decade or so to see more and more stars for genre books that sometimes can get overlooked in these “best of” rankings when compared to more “literary” counterparts.
Whats Up in YA
Sign up for What’s Up In YA? to receive all things young adult literature.
But rather than hang out in quotation mark land, let’s get into some of the best of the best in YA for 2025 so far.
Book Riot’s Best YA Books of 2025 So Far
Oathbound by Tracy Deonn
Bree Matthews must decide whom she can trust as the threats against her life mount. Selwyn is losing his battle with Demonia, and Nick is eight steps into his deadly fifty-step plan to save Bree and Sel. Separated from the Legendborn Order and cut off from her ancestors, Bree finds herself alone with the enemy, learning to balance King Arthur’s powers and Rootcraft. She knew gaining control over her powers and making a bargain with a dangerous being would cost her, but she was not sure she could pay the price. One thing’s for sure: Deonn’s third novel in The Legendborn Cycle is electric, heartbreaking, and absolutely stunning. – R. Nassor
On Again, Awkward Again by Erin Entrada Kelly and Kwame Mbalia
Geek out with this younger YA book, which follows two high school freshmen learning how to navigate school, friendship, family drama, and falling in love for the very first time. Pacy and Cecil meet on their first day of school, but neither has it together enough to fess up to their feelings. Both are forced into helping plan the freshman dance, and no matter how much they try to deny what’s going on, the sparks only get brighter. The dynamic writing duo behind this book has created two memorable characters who will have you weighing in on their ongoing battle: Star Wars or Star Trek? – Me!
(And you cannot miss the interview this fantastic author duo did with me for Hey YA about this book, about collaborative writing, about humor, and about writing “younger” YA books)
Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins
The latest installment in Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games dystopian series covers the Games of Haymitch Abernathy. Teenage Haymitch is warm, bright, and deeply in love with Lenore Dove Baird, a far cry from the mentor we meet with Katniss in the original trilogy. From Haymitch’s July 4th birthday and double the number of tributes on Reaping Day, this book refuses to slow down. Just as readers and tributes think they’ve learned the Capitol’s rules, something new and terrible arrives. Collins masterfully sets up for later events in the series while maintaining an overwhelming sense of dread. Brutal and truthful, this novel could not be more timely. – Courtney Rogers
Trans History: A Graphic Novel: From Ancient Times to the Present Day by Alex L. Combs and Andrew Eakett
This is an excellent introduction to trans history in comic format, from ancient history to interviews with trans people today. It’s a broad yet thorough glimpse into the myriad of ways gender has been expressed throughout time, and the ways trans people have been oppressed and erased from history. The beautiful illustrations enhanced and made the details more accessible. While listed as young adult, I would recommend it for anyone who wants to better understand the history of gender expression and transness, no matter their age. My only complaint is that I wanted an entire book for each chapter! I didn’t want it to end! – Margaret Kingsbury
The Best Books of 2025 So Far, According To The Stars
The titles below are those which have earned the highest number of starred reviews so far this year and were published in the first half of 2025. I’m sticking to books with 3, 4, or 5 starred reviews in the trades (there are currently no YA books with six starred reviews or they’d be included as well).
5 Starred Reviews
(S)Kin by Ibi Zoboi
This a novel in verse is based on Caribbean folklore following 15-year-old Marisol, who is the daughter of a soucouyant. When the new moon arrives each month, Marisol sheds her skin and turns into a fireball, launched into the sky where she must sip from other people’s lives to sustain her own. That is really difficult in Brooklyn, where it seems the lights never dim and folks keep themselves locked inside at night. Marisol wishes she didn’t need to do this, but her mother kept her tied to their magical past.
Genevieve, 17, is dealing with a skin condition that, in addition to her new baby siblings, keeps her up all night long. There’s a hunger inside her that wants nothing more than to recall her estranged mother. But it’ll be a new nanny in her house that begins to show a link between Genevieve and Marisol and it goes far more than skin deep.
Death in the Jungle: Murder, Betrayal, and the Lost Dream of Jonestown by Candace Flemming
I loved this book so very much, and would I have had more picks for “best of,” I’d have included it. You can read my in-depth review of it over here, and put it in your mental calendar that I’ll be talking with the author for an episode of Hey YA later this summer.
Jim Jones, leader of one of the most notorious cults in history, The People’s Temple, managed to convince 900 people to drink cyanide to their ultimate deaths. But how did he do it? This book traces Jones’s story from his youth growing up during the Great Depression to where and how he convinced people to follow him and his beliefs. You’ll follow Jones and his devotees from California to their off-grid Jonestown compound in the depths of Guyana.
Song of a Blackbird by Maria van Lieshout
Told in two timelines, this comic shares the journey of Emma Bergsma who, in 1943 Amsterdam, is so disgusted by watching Jewish families being sent to concentration camps that she joins the Dutch Resistance. She knows the work she’s going to take on is important.
In 2011, also Amsterdam, Annick needs a bone marrow donor for her oma. Her world is upended though when Annick learns that her oma was adopted, and it’s through a signature on several art prints on the wall–reading “Emma B”–that Annick may discover the truth of her family’s lineage.
4 Starred Reviews
I Am The Swarm by Hayley Chewins
The women in Nell’s family have always been gifted — err, rather cursed — with some kind of magic when they turn 15. The magic is cool, but there’s always some kind of not-great side effect. Nell’s mom is a different age every single day, which means Nell often feels like she doesn’t have the mother she needs. Nell’s sister bleeds music and wants nothing more than to get the songs inside of her outside of her.
So when Nell wakes up and sees ladybugs lighting up her piano keys, she thinks she’s okay. But then come the other bugs, each seeming to connect to an emotion she’s feeling. Moths show up when she’s disappointed. Beetles, when she’s feeling judged. And then there are the wasps that arrive at the hint of Nell’s anger.
The only way Nell seems to be able to make the unpleasant creatures disappear is to lock her darker feelings inside. But is it a life if she can’t express what she’s truly feeling?
The Corruption of Hollis Brown by K. Ancrum
This is a queer love story unlike any I’ve ever come across. There’s Hollis, who lives in a dead-end kind of blue-collar town, and who only seems to enjoy himself when he’s with his popular girl best friends…or fighting. But his tendency to throw hands isn’t his only problem—once he meets a stranger named Walt, he ends up making a deal at the crossroads. Now, he’s losing control of his body and mind to Walt, a ghost with a violent past who has some scores to settle. The two of them eventually start working together to achieve Walt’s goal, but then they grow closer. The resulting bond becomes romantic, and I’m sure I don’t have to tell you how awkward it is to low-key be in love with the ghost who’s possessing you. – Erica Ezefedi
The Rose Bargain by Sasha Peyton Smith
It’s London, 1848, but for four hundred years, an immortal fae queen has ruled after tricking her way into power. To keep up appearances, Queer Mor allows each of her subjects the opportunity to bargain for one of their deepest desires.
It’s about to be Ivy’s turn for this opportunity, but she’s feeling hopeless about her fate. The Queen can’t possibly fix everything that’s wrong . . . or can she?
Worried about her lack of romantic prospects, Ivy learns of a competition the Queen is holding that would give away the hand of her son, Prince Bram. Ivy quickly signs onto the competition, and it’s not long before she discovers she’s a front runner. That’s thanks to Prince Bram’s brother, who promises to help Ivy win–but it comes with a price.
3 Starred Reviews
A Bird in the Air Means We Can Still Breathe by Mahogany L. Browne
This is an interconnected collection of poems and stories from a variety of voices all living through and experiencing the COVID-19 pandemic in New York City. One teen is working on a story about armageddon, while another wrestles with depression following the loss of her parents to the virus. There are adult voices included, but this is a story focused on the teens and what they did during one of the most confusing and scary moments of their lives.
Banned Together: Our Fight for Readers’ Rights edited by Ashley Pérez
Banned Together features a wide array of stories, told through fiction, comic, nonfiction, essays, and more. Each focuses on what’s happening when books get banned, and in addition to the stories, there are practical ways young people can get involved in preserving the right to read. Debbie Fong illustrated the collection, so in addition to being informative, it’s a visual treat. Among the contributors are Kyle Lukoff, Nikki Grimes, Padma Venkatraman, Maia Kobabe, and so many more. This book has tons of resources included for readers who want even more when they’ve finished. And for teens who like seeing people like them making a difference in the world, they’ll discover teen activists working to end book bans.
Everything Is Poison by Joy McCullough
In early 17th century Rome, Carmela Tofana is eager to go behind the scenes of her mother’s apothecary. So when she’s finally invited back when she turns 16, Carmela begins to see that for every lovely potion concocted, there are others that aren’t especially pleasant. But it’s Aqua Tofana, one of the deadliest potions imaginable, that causes worry and fear for Carmela. It could kill them all if they’re not careful. . .and keeping it a secret will be tough.
This one blends McCollough’s signature verse with prose.
Fable for the End of the World by Ava Reid
Caerus controls all of society, and they’re able to do that by bankrupting the lower class. Inesa lives among the poorest in society, and she and her brother run a taxidermy shop to try to survive. Her father, a prepper, is long gone, and her mother is constantly sick—”sick”—and racking up untold amounts of debt. Her mom has so much debt that Inesa has been tapped as the next Lamb for Caerus’s televised assassination event.
Melinoë is a trained Caerus assassin. She’s just come off a run where she was forced to kill a small child, and she’s also struggling with the failure of Caerus’s technology to wipe her memory of what happened. She keeps having terrible flashbacks, and though she’s determined to do her job as an assassin, it’s made harder as her memory keeps popping up before her eyes.
It’s now Inesa who Melinoë needs to kill. But what happens when the two girls find themselves outside the realm of technology thanks to some glitches? Do they keep playing the roles they’re assigned from Caerus? Or do they take a different route and work to help one another survive?
(Psst: you can listen to Ava Reid talk about this book, about fandom, and about YA dystopia more broadly in this interview she did with me for Hey YA).
Hunger’s Bite by Taylor Robin
This graphic novel has been on none of my lists and I have not seen it mentioned before finding it among the most starred titles this year. I both love and hate that–love that it means discovering something new and hate that it means the title might be falling quite under the radar.
Alas!
Neeta Pandey and Emery Botwrigh have grown up on the SS Lark. They’re at the point, though, where they’re trying to decide what to do with their futures. Emery wants to sail the Lark like her father; Neeta wants to travel the world, but not necessarily aboard the Lark. There’s a big problem: Mr. Honeycutt, new owner of the Lark.
The rich passengers love Mr. Honeycutt. But the crew? They don’t love him. He makes their lives horrible, and it doesn’t help that the rich passengers seem to be turning into something decidedly not human, which is pushing staff to the ends of their patience.
There’s something on the ship, and it’s not human. It’ll be up to Neeta, Emery, and the vampire-secret agent-paranormal investigator Wick Farley, to figure out what’s going on–and what they need to do to save everyone from being consumed by its hunger.
Run Away With Me by Brian Selznick
Danny’s spending summer in Rome as his mom is working at a mysterious museum. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for a 16-year-old, of course, and he’s taking advantage of getting to know the ancient city. That’s when he encounters Angelo.
Before long, Danny and Angelo are spending every moment together. At first, it’s all about the city. Soon, though, they begin to share bits and pieces of their own lives with one another. That helps them build a home between them and romance begins to flourish.
But as much as Danny worries about telling Angelo about never feeling like he has had a home or fallen in love with another boy, the reality is that Angelo might be harboring even darker secrets that could end things between the two before they ever really begin.
The Otherwhere Post by Emily J. Taylor
Maeve Abenthy lost everything seven years ago. She’s been living under a fake name, moving constantly, as she’s trying to avoid being connected to her father’s history of crimes. So when Maeve gets a mysterious letter with the phrase “your father was innocent,” she knows she needs to figure out where it came from and what it means.
She takes an apprenticeship with the Otherwhere Post. There, she’ll learn the dangerous and magical art of scriptomancy, which allows for enchanting letters and sending them to other worlds. Maeve can’t outrun her past or her father, though, and the more she begins to discover about him, the more worried she becomes about her identity and the secrets she’s keeping.
As she begins to unravel her father’s secrets through the apprenticeship, she’s begun to receive threats herself to stop investigating…and her mentor is well aware she’s hiding something from him, too.
As always, we’ll get your votes for the best YA books of 2025 when we get to the second season of best of lists at the end of the year. I always appreciate hearing what readers find the best because sometimes, it’s a title that hasn’t showed up on other lists and it can be nice to give it a little more attention.