From discovering new-to-me books to seeing the themes readers want to discuss and share, I look forward to seeing what the popular book clubs announce every month as their book selections. There are also fun surprises, like seeing which books get picked more than once and the new book clubs that pop up.
Now that we’re closing out the year, I took a look over the books that the popular book clubs picked in 2025 to put together a new reading list. After scouring the lists, analyzing them, and making a spreadsheet, I created several categories with a few picks for each. There are six books picked by multiple book clubs, three interesting picks, three highly rated picks, three selections that felt like they met the moment of 2025, three books with adaptations, and three under-the-radar books that deserve more attention.
From a dystopian novel about government overreach to a translated novel set in 1930s Japanese-occupied Taiwan, this list is as varied as the popular book clubs and their readers. They weren’t all published in 2025, but they were book club picks this year.
The 6 Books Picked By Multiple Book Clubs
- Homeseeking by Karissa Chen (The Audacious Book Club; Subtle Asian Book Club; Good Morning America Book Club)
- The Dream Hotel by Laila Lalami (Read with Jenna; The Audacious Book Club)
- Cursed Daughters by Oyinka Braithwaite (Eclectix The Book Club; Read with Jenna; The Audacious Book Club)
In The Club
Sign up for In The Club to get tips and tricks to keep your book group well-met, well-read, and well-fed.

- Frankenstein by Mary Shelley (The Stacks Book Club; Inklings Book Club)
- Great Black Hope by Rob Franklin (The Audacious Book Club; Eclectix The Book Club)
- King of Ashes by S.A. Cosby (Mocha Girls Read; Eclectix The Book Club)
3 Selections That Felt The Most 2025
The Dream Hotel Laila Lalami
Chosen by Read with Jenna and The Audacious Book Club in March and April.
Jenna said: “This is a book about how technology shackles us even when it connects us, how it can make us not feel present, and it’s a commentary on that.”
Roxanne Gay said: “It is no surprise that Lalami wrote a fascinating, terrifying novel about finding and trying to hold on to humanity in the midst of dystopia, or that this book represents a refinement and a distillation of so much of her earlier work.”
Laila Lalami on The Today Show: Laila Lalami shares how oversleeping inspired The Dream Hotel
Marsha: The Joy and Defiance of Marsha P. Johnson by Tourmaline
Chosen by The Audacious Book Club in June.
Roxanne Gay said: “Drawing on extensive archival research, interviews, and the work of scholars such as Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha and Saidiya Hartman, Tourmaline reads Stonewall as a site of disability and madness and Marsha’s narrative—and indeed her life—as a kind of critical fabulation, a necessary reimagining of the often whitewashed historical record, by a Black trans woman who was a key instigator in a revolutionary moment that fueled the gay liberation movement.”
To the Moon and Back by Eliana Ramage
Reese’s Book Club pick for September.
Eliana Ramage’s author essay: “At its heart, this is a book about belonging, and belief in our shared future: that we may choose—person by person—to show up for one another. I hope that, when you finish this book, you’re left with a feeling of connection. To your family, your people, and humankind. Wherever we come from, and wherever we may go.”
3 Highly Rated / Awarded Picks
The Reformatory by Tananarive Due
Selected by a members’ vote in July by Mocha Girls Read.
This horror novel’s setting is based on the Dozier School for Boys and, in part, on Tananarive Due’s great uncle’s experience.
Awards: Los Angeles Times Book Prize Winner, Winner of the Bram Stoker Award, and the Shirley Jackson Award.
Starred review: Library Journal, Booklist, Kirkus
One Crazy Summer by Rita Williams-Garcia
Selected by Eclectix The Book Club in September.
What Eclectix said: “We have never read a middle grade novel as a book club for adults before, but this notable title seems like a great close to summer and an opportunity to explore a new genre through a set of sisters.”
Awards: Coretta Scott King Award, Newbery Medal Honor, Scott O’Dell Award for Historical Fiction.
3 Interesting Picks
Forest Euphoria: The Abounding Queerness of Nature by Patricia Ononiwu Kaishian
Sapph-Lit’s November pick.
What Sapph-List said: “This book explores the abounding queerness of nature, challenging norms, and highlighting unusual aspects like fungi with many sexes and intersex slugs.”
The Compound by Aisling Rawle
People Like Us by Jason Mott
3 Picks & Their Adaptations
Count My Lies by Sophie Stava
Selected by Good Morning America’s GMA Book Club in March.
What GMA said: “With a razor-sharp plot and shocking twists, Count My Lies is an unputdownable suspense novel about deception, privilege and the price of keeping up appearances.”
About the upcoming adaptation: The book is being adapted into a limited series that will star Lindsay Lohan and Shailene Woodley and will stream on Hulu.
Beloved by Toni Morrison
Selected by Eclectix The Book Club in October.
Eclectix The Book Club said: “I know I’m not the only one who hasn’t read Beloved by Toni Morrison yet, so it is with the greatest pleasure to invite you all to join @EclectixTheBookClub to finally give it a go with an incredible group of readers this October.”
About the adaptation: This is a film that was produced by Harpo Films, which came out in 1998, and starred Oprah Winfrey, Danny Glover, and Thandiwe Newton. You can see the trailer from way back when.
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
Selected by two book clubs in October: Jack Edward’s Inklings and The Stacks Book Club.
Inklings said: “To celebrate the spooky season, we’re reading Mary Shelley’s gothic tale, written as part of a contest with Lord Byron to see who could write the creepiest tale. In the process, she essentially invented the sci-fi genre, and wrote a novel that has stood the test of time.”
The Stacks Book Club said: “For the first time ever on The Stacks we’re leaning into horror and ‘spooky season’ with Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. This 1818 novel follows Victor Frankenstein, who creates life with body parts and unorthodox scientific methods. The book is widely considered the first science fiction novel, and Frankenstein’s creation has become one of the most iconic monsters in the cultural imagination.”
About the (newest) adaptation: Guillermo Del Toro finally got to adapt Frankenstein, which is now streaming on Netflix and stars Oscar Isaac, Jacob Elordi, and Mia Goth.
Jack Edwards interviews: Guillermo Del Toro and Rachael Marsay (the Roy Davids Archivist of Modern Literary Archives and Manuscripts at the Bodleian Libraries).
Angela Flournoy joined Traci Thomas for a discussion: Ep. 396 Frankenstein by Mary Shelley — The Stacks Book Club (Angela Flournoy)
3 Under-the-Radar Selections That Deserve More Attention
Taiwan Travelogue by Yáng Shuāng-zǐ, 楊双子, Lin King (Translator)
Subtle Asian Book Club’s first pick of 2025.
Taiwan Travelogue ended up on my TBR because of this book club, and it’s one of my favorite reads of the year. It’s a delightful gem set in the ’30s, following a Japanese woman who becomes fascinated with Taiwan and her interpreter. She also has a bottomless pit for a stomach as she eats her way around the country.
You can join the book club’s Discord for all the book discussions.
Go with the Flow by Lily Williams and Karen Schneemann
Colored Television by Danzy Senna
Selected by Eclectix The Book Club in April.
Eclectix The Book Club said: “This will be the first book I’ve read by this author, but I have heard nothing but amazing reviews about Senna’s work! Satirical fiction always leaves me with a good chuckle and a thought-provoking examination of our society, so I’m excited to finally read Colored Television with everyone.”
3 Best Covers
- Fearless and Free: A Memoir by Josephine Baker (Mocha Girls Read, September)
- Moderation by Elaine Castillo (The Audacious Book Club, September)
- The Art Thief: A True Story of Love, Crime, and a Dangerous Obsession by Michael Finkel (The Stacks Book Club, June)
And if you need any more book club recommendations, check out the biggest book clubs’ December picks—there’s still time to join and read along!



































English (US) ·