The Most Disappointing Queer Books I Read in 2025

3 days ago 6

I Can Fix Her by Rae Wilde is a horror novella that I had high hopes for. It about a toxic sapphic relationship that spirals into the surreal. Unfortunately, it didn’t work for me in practice. It felt mostly like nightmare visuals without much else to hold it together.

the cover of A Psalm for the Wild-Built

I know this will be controversial, but another book I was disappointed by this year was A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers. Partly, it was my high expectations. I love cozy sci-fi and fantasy, and I am a big fan of Becky Chambers’s The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet, so I thought this would be a new favourite. Instead, I was bit bored. I think this would be a great graphic novel, but the novel fell flat for me.

I picked up Housemates by Emma Copley Eisenberg for book club, and while many of the other book club members loved it, I found it a slog. Like the above two books, it’s very visually descriptive—my “inner eye” has terrible vision, so that’s a common reason I struggle with a book.

Finally, I have the one book I wouldn’t recommend to anyone: The Elegant Courtly Life of the Tea Witch Vol. 1 by Ameko Kaerudo. I was confused while reading it, because I thought it was a sapphic/yuri manga series, but it seemed to be about the friendship between a 12-year-old and adult. Then they went on a date. NOPE. (And yes, they specify on the page that she’s 12!)

Read Entire Article