Jamie Canavés is the Tailored Book Recommendations coordinator and Unusual Suspects mystery newsletter writer–in case you’re wondering what you do with a Liberal Arts degree. She’s never met a beach she didn’t like, always says yes to dessert, loves ‘80s nostalgia, all forms of entertainment, and can hold a conversation using only gifs. You can definitely talk books with her on Litsy and Goodreads. Depending on social media’s stability maybe also Twitter and Bluesky.
Because publishing is not stingy in its overall quantity release for mystery and thriller books, I decided to split the Best of the Past 10 Years into one for just mysteries and now one for just thrillers. While a book can be both a mystery and a thriller, for each list I focused on either the mystery or the thriller being the major component for the majority of the book. Once again, I counted the past ten years as books published in the US from 2014 through the year 2023, and I broke my picks out into categories for what the book is the best of to hit a wide range of tropes and reading tastes.
So what is a thriller, and why can you find it in other genres like SFF? Thrillers rely heavily on eliciting a response from the reader to make things feel intense. Many times this is done through quick pacing, but it can also be through heightened elements like action and suspense. While a cozy mystery wants to lull you into a feeling of relaxed reading, a thriller wants you to be excited, flying through pages. Using different tropes and hooks, these 10 thrillers had me fully invested, tearing through the stories, and aware that if I wanted to get any sleep I should not pick them up before bed.
Best On The Run Thriller
She Rides Shotgun by Jordan Harper
Not only is Jordan Harper fantastic at writing gritty crime stories with action that make you feel as if you are there with the characters, he also wrote one of my all-time favorite child characters, eleven-year-old Polly. “She had a teddy bear in her arms and murder in her eyes.” I remain utterly confused as to why he’s not a blockbuster author in the crime genre.
Nate and his family get marked for death by the Aryan Brotherhood right before he’s released from prison. Upon release he finds his ex-wife and her new partner murdered, forcing him to grab his estranged 11-year-old daughter Polly and go on the run to keep her alive.
Best Will-Emotionally-Wreck-You Thriller
Sadie by Courtney Summers
I was floored by emotions reading this book. Courtney Summers is brilliant at writing a novel that keeps the graphic violence off the page while creating a white-knuckle page-turner that will destroy you.
Sadie has one mission: find her sister’s killer and kill him. This is what she sets out to do. On her trail is a radio personality with a new podcast about Sadie’s sister’s murder who wants to find Sadie…
Best Did-He-or-Didn’t-He Legal Thriller
The Verdict by Nick Stone
Nick Stone does a hell of a job combining all my favorite things—a court case from beginning to end, firm politics, collecting clues, did-he-or-didn’t he?!—all with a hell of a hook!
Terry Flynt is assigned a new case: after accepting a humanitarian award, Vernon James is accused of murdering a woman in his hotel room. And that’s not even the hook! Flynt knows James from childhood, as his sworn enemy, but he takes the case without revealing this to anyone…
Unusual Suspects Newsletter
Sign up to Unusual Suspects to receive news and recommendations for mystery/thriller readers.
Thank you for signing up! Keep an eye on your inbox.
Best Revenge Thriller
The Collective by Alison Gaylin
I love a good revenge novel, and not only does Alison Gaylin deliver a revenge thriller, but she also explores the cost of grief and revenge.
Camille Gardner is livid that her daughter’s accused killer is being awarded a humanitarian award instead of facing any level of consequences. The scene she creates in response brings a secret organization, the collective, into her life, allowing her to join an online group where you can enact justice for someone else in the group who is currently grieving…
Best Assassins Thriller
Bullet Train (Assassins #2 ) by Kōtarō Isaka, Sam Malissa (Translator)
One of my favorite things about Japanese mystery and thrillers is that most have an element of a character(s) who contemplate(s) the world and society. Isaka manages to do this while also adding comedy of errors, dark humor, and action to a twisty plot.
On a bullet train from Tokyo to Morioka you’ll find criminals and victims—including two criminals with a rescued kidnap victim that they’re doing a terrible job of rescuing. On this train is also a suitcase full of money and a handful of assassins…
A note on the series: Bullet Train published first in the US but in Japan the first book published in the series was Three Assassins. Bullet Train can be read as a standalone, and the series is worth reading.
Best One-Last-Job Thriller
Blacktop Wasteland by S.A. Cosby
S.A. Cosby brings his setting and characters to life to the point that you will feel yourself strapped into the car as it flies down the road trying to get away! His books are a great example that fast-paced thrillers can also have all the depth and character development of excellent writing.
Beauregard “Bug” Montage is drowning in debt and hard times. As Beauregard, he’s an honest mechanic and family man. As Bug, he’s the best wheelman/getaway driver. When he’s presented with a heist that will solve his problems, he takes it. And then finds out just how many things can go wrong.
Best Reluctant Spy Thriller
East of Hounslow (Jay Qasim #1) by Khurrum Rahman
I am a sucker for thrillers with humor, and the character voice here—of a reluctant spy who has nothing about life figured out—shines from the opening.
Jay, a young man in West London, is about to have his life rocked by MI5. He’s a low-level drug dealer with nothing about life figured out other than his love for his BMW (yes, the car). He has zero desire to be involved in political and religious issues, but after a series of events get him in trouble with his supplier, MI5 steps in to blackmail him into going undercover for them. They see a Pakistani Muslim who can infiltrate an extremist group and report back information. Even though Jay is very much not up for being a spy, he feels he has no choice.
Best Everyone’s Got Secrets Thriller
Little Secrets by Jennifer Hillier
I picked this book up with the intention of sampling the beginning to decide whether to put it in my to-read pile or not, and before I knew it I had read the first half of the book because Jennifer Hillier knows how to hook me! I really liked that Hillier wrote a page-turning thriller that didn’t rely on the black-and-white “good and bad” trope but rather explores how everyone is capable of many degrees of good and bad depending on the situations they’re put in.
Marin Machado’s young son was abducted a year ago and the case has remained unsolved. With the FBI no longer actively looking for him, Machado secretly hires a PI. The PI comes with news, not of finding her son, but that her husband has a mistress. Now Machado has something new to obsess about…
Best Intensity
The Good Daughter by Karin Slaughter
I almost came out of my skin with anxiety from Slaughter’s ability to put me in the violent, intense, and terrifying scenes of this thriller. And it always came as a surprise because she’s very good at getting me invested and lulled into the characters’ world and then BAM! I’m gripping the book so hard I could break it!
The patriarch of the Quinn family is a lawyer who represents people accused of crimes like rape and murder, which is why someone burned down their home and then attacked the family. Thirty years later the youngest daughter, still living in the same small town, witnesses a violent crime only to have her father represent the accused…
Best Under-the-Radar Author
The Nothing Man by Catherine Ryan Howard
Catherine Ryan Howard quickly became an automatic buy for me as her thrillers never disappoint in the initial hook and then keep me fully invested in how things will play out. As a testament to how much I can’t resist her books, I read a pandemic-set thriller in the pandemic when I was 100% against reading anything related to the pandemic (56 Days).
I love that all her thrillers are set in Ireland, explore women’s lives, and give voice to victims. The Liar’s Girl is a great did-he-or-didn’t-he mystery perfect for fans of past and present storylines and fictional serial killer stories. In The Nothing Man you get a lead author with a hell of a twist and also the POV of a serial killer, which Howard uses to dismantle the weird and gross obsession with serial killers. Run Time puts you on the set of a psychological horror film and plays with all the fun tropes. The Trap follows two women—the sister of a missing woman and a woman wishing to be a detective—along with a man with a woman in his trunk telling the story of how he came to be a serial killer. You see what I mean about a hook?!
I will be dropping everything to read Howard’s 2025 release, Burn After Reading, the second I get my hands on a copy!